EMN Ireland | www.emn.ie

Case Law

<< Back

AA & Anor v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform & Anor

Applicant/Plaintiff: A.A. & Anor
Respondent/Defendant: Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform & Anor
Citation/s: [2005] 4 IR 564
Court/s: High Court
High Court
Judgment Date/s: 16 November 2005
Judge: Clarke
Category:Deportation
Keywords:Deportation; Deportation Order; European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR); revocation; family
Country of Origin: Nigeria
URL: http://www.courts.ie/Judgments.nsf/597645521f07ac9a80256ef30048ca52/585e7b82bd[...]

The applicant, a Nigerian national, married an Irish citizen after a deportation order was made against him. He then requested that the Minister revoke the order in light of the new circumstances. The Minister refused this request  and the applicant sought to quash both the deportation order and the refusal to revoke the order.

The High Court refused leave, stating that the Minister was obliged to consider, inter alia, new circumstances in the form of family rights such as those that arose in the instant case but finding that it appeared that the Minister had taken into account the fact of the possible impending marriage in declining to revoke the order. The Court noted that the applicant had been in the relationship for sixteen months prior to the marriage and had known of the proposed deportation and of the precarious nature of his status in the State since December 2002.

Principles:

The Minister for Justice is obliged to consider new circumstances in the form of family rights where a proposed deportee seeks revocation of a deportation order.


Download Adobe Acrobat Reader PDF

Key European case law

A Member State is obliged to examine an asylum application if transfer would expose the applicant to a serious risk of a violation of fundamental rights

Court of Justice of the EU ruling on the transfer of asylum seekers under the EU Dublin Regulation Cases C-411/10 and C-493/10 M.E.


McCarthy: Rights of EU citizens to regularise the residence of their non-EU spouse

Court of Justice of the EU judgment in the case of McCarthy v Secretary of State for the Home Department (in UK).


Zambrano: Rights of non-EU parents of a child with European citizenship to live in the EU

Court of Justice of the EU judgment in the case of Zambrano v Office national de l’emploi (in Belgium).

Back to top